It's all about making the best entertainment possible. And when a piece is well done, it doesn't matter what medium the content is shot on or where it's shown. It takes guts to make the most innovative, most creative content available. Evaluate on the quality of content produced. Rate 1-10; 10 being the best.
This is a business after all, and being compensated in a timely manner (or at all) is big part of the job. In a freelance industry, this can make or break a professional relationship. Who pays on time? Who pays the kill fee and who doesn't? Evaluate on the promptness and consistency of payment. Rate 1-10; 10 being the best
The business of being creative is a tough nut to crack. It's often expected that editors consistently work long, hard hours. As defined by the US Department of Labor, a standard work week is 40 hours. Evaluate on the weekly hours expected as compared to those standardized by the US Department of Labor.
Cleanliness and facility upkeep greatly impacts those who work within it. A proper workspace that's designed and built to create, complete with ergonomic chairs, monitors at appropriate level, sound proofing, and all the proper editing hardware, are all important factors in producing the environment necessary to create media. Evaluate on facility maintenance and overall professional appearance.
Some things don't fit in to a category. This is the catch-all for the rest of your compliments/complaints. The more information we give them, the better the understand where they stand. Let it out!